I took the CFP in March of 2007 and passed it and just recently sat for the CFA Level 1 a few weeks ago in December.
Thoughts on the CFA exam–
-Material was much more difficult to grasp verses the CFP. Quant, Derivatives, and Econ where in much more depth and challenging.
-A lot more information in the CFA L1 curriculum. Between the CFAI books and the Schweser notes that I used just a huge amount to tackle.
-The six hours of the CFA exam seemed easier to get through vs. the 10 in the CFP.
-CFA exam questions seemed to be pretty straight forward. Wording and the use of double negatives and trickery were really pretty minimal.
-Don’t know if I passed the Dec. Level 1 but really expected it to be more difficult than it was. I know that L2 and L3 are different monsters and definitely take a humble approach to the CFA curriculum and it’s tests.
Thoughts on the CFP exam.
-The use of trickery in wording and similar answers was really quite prevelant. CFP goes by the basis of choose the MOST correct answer. There were a lot of questions that there were 2 answers that were correct and you had to pick the most correct. From a comparison standpoint, the CFA test was much more fair.
-If you look at the core books from Kaplan, the readings and books are a breeze to get through. With 12 and 14 point font you should be able to get through 1 of 6 books in about a week. From a reading perspective the CFP curriculum is MUCH MUCH easier in that aspect.
-The format for the CFP was more difficult in the sense that it had straight up multiple questions, vignette, and case studies. From a testing standpoint the CFP was a little more difficult.
From an accredidation standpoint I really really look forward to acheiving the CFA designation. I work in a wealth consulting role and feel that the CFA does the best job of preparing you for Portfolio Management especially with larger accounts. It’s a huge chore to get through but I really really enjoy the curriculum. The CFA is my biggest goal and can hopefully move on to L2 and take in June 08.
The CFP curriculum is a good thing for everyone to know. The basics, insurance, portfolio managment, income tax planning, estate planning, etc… Good overall info to know and I use it all the time in my business and everyday life. I’ve seen that the CFP gets knocked a lot on this forum and in a lot of instances it could be justified. I hope in the future that the CFP goes more in depth into the portfolio manangement, similar to the CFA curriculum but who knows if they will. With the CFP and the CFA pennsteric you’ll do really well. Like someone mentioned above two of the top 3 that you could have in the Finance world (CPA being the 3rd).
Pennsteric. I would take the CFP in March and get it over with. You should have ample time to study for it and pass if you’ve finished your educational requirements. If you retained your investment learning from Level 1 you’ll rock the investment portion of the CFP. Which is 1/6th of the curriculum.
As big daddy mentioned I would recommend a class like KEN ZAHN or John Hopkins. That will help you prepare for common tricks that hints to pass the CFP exam.
You should have more than enough time to study for it and pass. That would allow more time to focus on the CFA. If you are interested I can forward over my handwritten notes and cheat sheets that I used for the test. Seemed to pretty much cover everything the test threw at me. Good luck and hopefully my -$.02 help. GMofDEN