I think Illinois has a decent non-quant MSF. Also, I was under the impression that Princeton's program was relatively non-quant (or at least much less so that the mathematical fin/fin eng programs at NYU, Chicago, and Berkeley).
I was in a similar situation a while back. I wanted to go to a non-quant MSF, but I just couldn't find a program that really excited me.
So instead I'm starting an MBA in the fall at a school that offers both an MBA and one of these math fin/fin eng degrees. For my electives, I'll be able to take several math fin/fin eng courses. And with the MBA degree, I think I'll have more flexibility down the road (and won't get pigeonholed into some bond pricing job).
It depends on what your goals are, but I think that you could do pretty much whatever you want with a CFA and an MBA from a good school.