did the angoff method hurt me?

[luminus]

This is my 2014 level 2 matrix (band 10 fail)
below 50%: quants, econ, fixed income
between 51 and 70%: corporate finance, derivatives, portfolio management, ethics
above 70%: equity, financial reporting and analysis, alternative investments
you think the angoff method could get to the point where if you missed a “key” question you get penalized more than if you failed a “regular” question?

 

[dwheaton]

I do not think that is the case at all. Although possible, I have yet to come across a case in which someone failed 3 subjects and passed the exam.
Also, if your conjecture is accurate, you scored above 70 on the two most important topics for level 2.

 

[Imran Mani]

luminus wrote:
This is my 2014 level 2 matrix (band 10 fail)
below 50%: quants, econ, fixed income
between 51 and 70%: corporate finance, derivatives, portfolio management, ethics
above 70%: equity, financial reporting and analysis, alternative investments
you think the angoff method could get to the point where if you missed a “key” question you get penalized more than if you failed a “regular” question?

Its amazing dude rather quite ASTONISHING that you didn’t passed. just compare your result with my Passed Level 2 result.
Greater Than 70% in Equity Investments, Financial Reporting & Analysis, Fixed Income Investments
51-70% in Corporate Finance, Derivatives, Ethical & Professional Standards
Less Than or Equal to 50% in Alternative Investments, Economics, Portfolio Management, Quantitative Methods
What I feel is we don’t know where the actual result numbers are in the Ranges, For Example, Two persons got the same Asteriks in Result Cards, One got Failed and one got Passed now one gets 3 above 70% in same Areas but the actual numbers he got are 95% in Each and the failed candidate has 72% in the same Each 3 Areas. Never the less keep on working hard to pass next time as this the Beatuy and Worth of CFA Exams.

 

[scorpiomanoj]

@luminous
Your possible scores could be a combination of the above:
AI : 83% or 100%
CF : 58% or 67%
Der : 58% or 67%
Econ : 0% or 17% or 33% or 50%
Equity : 71% or 75% or 79% or 83% or 88% or 92% or 96% or 100%
Ethics : 58% or 67%
FRA : 71% or 75% or 79% or 83% or 88% or 92% or 96% or 100%
FI : 0% or 17% or 33% or 50%
PM : 58% or 67%
Quant : 0% or 17% or 33% or 50%
Translating the above to the number of correct answers (not scores) gives a minimum possible correct answers of 67 out of 120 (56%) and the maximum possible correct answers of 95 out of 120 (79%). The same in terms of scores is a min of 201 and a max of 285 out of 360.
The definite narrowest MPS range is 68 to 76 out of 120 (ie, 204 to 228 out of 360). In percentage terms it is 56.7% to 63.3%.
See below the following scores
Score A
@ msc2488
Msc248’s min possible number of correct answers is 68 out of 120 (56.7%) and maximum possible no of correct answers is 95 out of 120 (79.2%). msc2488 has a failed result.
Score B
A score posted in Page 10 in the official cfa level ii results thread (last post of the page) placed btwn quotes
QUOTE
manuag
Jul 29th, 2014 12:18pm

• United States
• 36 AF Points

It was a close call, but passed.
Q#TopicMax Pts<=50%51%-70%>70%-Alternative Investments18*—Corporate Finance36–*-Derivatives36*—Economics18-*–Equity Investments72–*-Ethical & Professional Standards36–*-Financial Reporting & Analysis72-*–Fixed Income Investments18-*–Portfolio Management36-*–Quantitative Methods18*–
Thanks
Manuag
http://www.analystforum.com/forums/cfa-forums/cfa-level-ii-forum/91334701?page=9
UNQUOTE
manuag’s min possible score is 55 and max possible score is 76 out of 120. He has a pass result.
Now take the minimum possible scores of the failed result (msc2488) and that of the passed result (manuag). This is the MPS range which comes to 68 - 76 out of 120. In % terms it is 56.7% to 63.3%
Will post if I am able to further narrow the MPS range.
Anyone who require the excel file that provides the min and max possible scores automatically can send a request to my mail [email protected]

 

[Rogue Trader]

Still chunck 40% of the exam got in the middle range between 51-70 probably you were in the low range
Give it a shot next year, All the best!!