bchadwick wrote:
ohai wrote:
I’m not saying it’s necessarily true for this guy, but there’s nothing wrong with mentioning a possible outcome. In fact, wouldn’t it be irresponsible to *not* consider a negative outcome?
Also, surprised that you are basically saying “don’t state your opinion”. That’s the opposite of what a forum is for.
Ok, first of all, I did insert a smiley to try to indicate that my criticism - while real - was not intended to slam you for your post. That continues to be my basic attitude, but I’ll explain my thinking in more detail.
The guy has an MSF and wants to do a CFA. He’s clearly dedicated to the field to be doing that and while the CFA wont’ guarantee him a job, it’s much more likely that it will help him than many other people who start the process.
His inlaws are upset that he doesn’t seem to have enough time/attention to devote to his wife - which is something that is very imaginable, even if the CFA is exactly what he needs to move ahead…
…and your first serious suggestion to him, after this evidence is “well, maybe they’re right (with the implication that it would be better to give up)?”
…if the guy had a pain in his leg, would your advice be “Well, it could be terminal bone cancer, just sayin’.” It’s certainly a possibility… therefore it would be irresponsible not to list it? Let’s try to offer advice in the order of liklihoods.
–
I don’t attack your right to state your opinion, but I question your judgement and motive for saying it. It seems like it was said more out of the fun of dumping cold water on this guy rather than to offer an honest analysis of his situation. There’s nothing prohibited about that here, but I thought it was a cheap shot at someone else’s expense, and that’s why I said what I said.
The forum is for opinions, but it is also for the CFA and CFA candidate community to support each other, and while that doesn’t mean that it isn’t appropriate to dissuade people from investing large amounts of time if there is clear evidence that it will be useless for them, in this case, he has a problem that is not unknown in this group, even for those who will almost certainly benefit from the charter, and my opinion is that he deserves the benefit of the doubt on its usefulness.
Anyway… I like a lot of your other posts… it’s just that I don’t like these ones so much. And you are free to put your opinion, and I’ll be free to disagree with it (on those occasions when I do).