dwheats wrote:
Gurifissu wrote:Oh My God.
What I did was put the FV with a negative sign and the PV with a positive sign. Now i tried with PV negative sign and FV positive sign, and it gives me your numbers guys.
Seriously, what’s up with that? I thought we could put the negative sign either to the PV or the FV, as long as they had different signs?
You can….but the PMT must have the same sign as the FV.
Look at this equation:
-PV +PMT/(IRR) +(PMT+FV)/(IRR)^2 = 0
The PV always has the opposite sign of the PMT and the FV, and the FV and PMTs always have the same sign.
While this is true for bonds, it’s not necessarily true for all (constant payment) TVM problems.
It’s better to remember that the TVM buttons are cash flow buttons: you have to use the correct sign for the direction of the cash flows.
For normal bonds, if you view it from the bondholder’s perspective, PV is negative (a cash
outflow when he buys the bond), PMT and FV are positive (cash
inflows that he receives from the issuer for the coupon and principal payments); if you view it from the issuer’s perspective, PV is positive (a cash
inflow when he sells the bond), PMT and FV are negative (cash
outflows when he makes the coupon and principal payments).
But you can also use the TVM buttons to analyze, say, a savings account in which the investor makes an initial deposit and periodic deposits. If you view this from the investor’s perspective, PV and PMT are negative (
outflows when he makes deposits) and FV is positive (an
inflow when he closes the account); if you view it from the account’s perspective, PV and PMT are positive (
inflows into the account) and FV is negative (an
outflow when the account is closed).