myriam2222
New member
- Jun 18, 2026
- 0
- 0
Dear all,
I am a bit confused by a statement about commodity indices in the CFAI material saying “all of these indices are considered investable”.
My understanding was that indices were not instruments but simply a measure of value from which you can deduct some return and that such return could be achieved by replicating the components of the index.
I thought it was clear to me by now…
So what is an investable index? Does it just mean that the securities within this index are considered sufficiently liquid and free of other regulatory investment constraints for the investor to replicate this index in a satisfactory manner? Or does it mean that vehicles exist that already replicate these indexes so that you don’t have to do it yourself but simply invest in the vehicle? Or i am getting it all wrong here?
Thanks!
I am a bit confused by a statement about commodity indices in the CFAI material saying “all of these indices are considered investable”.
My understanding was that indices were not instruments but simply a measure of value from which you can deduct some return and that such return could be achieved by replicating the components of the index.
I thought it was clear to me by now…
So what is an investable index? Does it just mean that the securities within this index are considered sufficiently liquid and free of other regulatory investment constraints for the investor to replicate this index in a satisfactory manner? Or does it mean that vehicles exist that already replicate these indexes so that you don’t have to do it yourself but simply invest in the vehicle? Or i am getting it all wrong here?
Thanks!