ohai wrote:
First of all, I think we should congratulate Chad for pushing through this update with no noticeable malfunctions. I’m sure we will come to appreciate the enhanced functionality once we learn to use the new features.
With that being said, I was wondering if there was something you could do about the amount of white space between posts as they are displayed using the new layout. The white space creates a lot of fatigue when browsing the forums, as we need to scroll through a lot of empty space when navigating up and down the page.
For instance, here is the page for AF’s “General Discussion”. Using my screen size and resolution, I can see 14 topics on one page without scrolling.
http://www.analystforum.com/forums/cfa-forums/cfa-general-discussion
Compare that to say, Wilmott forums, where I can see 28 topics. So Wilmott’s page has twice the amount of information on one page, without sacrificing content.
http://www.wilmott.com/categories.cfm?catid=4
The same applies to the threads themselves. There are only 8 replies above mine, but I had to scroll the equivalent of 3 pages to get down here. Again, this creates a lot of user fatigue and will eventually reduce the frequency of visits. It would be great if there was some way to compress all these lines - preferably by making the comment boxes wider, and by chopping out some of the white space between text lines.
Better color contrast between thread replies and forum topics would also enhance readability.
Finally, would it be possible to make the comment text boxes (where you type comments) bigger? I just realized this while composing this message, but I feel like I’m typing a huge comment into a tiny text box with a tiny scroll bar. I imagine how this small text box would be highly frustrating for people who like to write very long academic replies (cough **bchadwick** cough).
Anyway, thanks again for the update. I hope others can share their thoughts about my comments.
Excellent.