It looks like a simple case. You are provided the Eo but not E1, so don’t calculate E1 using a growth rate, just assume the earnings will not grow. I know the formula is using E1 because you are forecasting a value so must use a forecasted value. However, in this question it is assumed that the best forecast is in fact the 2008 EPS, use that then. If E1 is provided, use E1; if not, use E0 with no growth and get the PVGO as always. Don’t bother too much on this